Coffee shops

Lucy’s

4.6 16 reviews Closed 134 Northern Blvd, Newbury, MA 01951, United States

Discover this place

Lucy’s is a coffee shop located at 134 Northern Blvd in Newbury, MA. The menu features classic breakfast items like English muffin toasts with butter or cream cheese, and hearty breakfast sandwiches made with fresh egg, cheddar cheese, and a choice of bacon or sausage, served on various breads including bagels and croissants. Beyond breakfast, Lucy’s offers a selection of freshly baked pastries such as blueberry muffins, scones, and buttermilk biscuits, including a take-and-bake option for home enjoyment. For dessert, options like brownies and chocolate chip cookies are available. The atmosphere at Lucy’s is informal and welcoming, designed to cater to early risers and casual visitors alike seeking a simple, quality meal or a coffee break. The focus remains on straightforward, traditional flavors made with care, making it a notable spot for locals looking for a reliable coffee and breakfast stop in Newbury.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Great coffee

Popular for

Breakfast

Dining options

Breakfast
Lunch
Seating

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Lucy’s before visiting.

Reviews for Lucy’s

4.6

16 reviews

100%

Review highlights

Based on 16 reviews

Lucy’s, a coffee shop located in Newbury, MA, consistently receives praise for its high-quality offerings and welcoming atmosphere. Reviewers frequently highlight the freshness and variety of food options, including standout pastries, donuts, and breakfast sandwiches on unique rolls. The coffee is regularly described as excellent, complementing the overall experience. Customers appreciate the fair pricing and the shop’s ability to serve both quick grabs and more leisurely visits, making it a favored spot for locals and visitors alike. Additionally, the friendly and attentive service contributes significantly to Lucy’s positive reputation. Overall, the brand is recognized not only for its product quality but also for its inviting environment and reliable customer service, positioning it as a notable destination in the Newburyport area and the nearby islands.

Marsha Waterhouse

Mar 24, 2026

Absolutely the best thing to happen to our island in a while. Quality. Freshness. Fair pricing. Thanks Lucy’s!

gobrien032

Mar 01, 2026

If you’re in any where near Newburyport, I highly recommend Lucy’s. If you’re on Plum Island you need to make this your go to

Jason Lambert

Feb 01, 2026

Stopped in for coffee and water. Had an excellent latte! Ended up trying the local donuts and cookies they had and they were as good as they looked. You could put this place in the middle of other coffee shops and it would still stand out. Amazing service, quality, and atmosphere. I've added it to my favorite places list!

Steve Fox

Jan 18, 2026

Great little breakfast spot, plenty of great food options, sandwiches, muffins etc

Amber Battaglia

Dec 30, 2025

The donuts are amazing here. The pastries, great. Didn't get to drink any coffee or tea but my husband said his coffee was good. Breakfast sandwiches were on a brioche type roll instead of an English and made all the difference. There's sandwiches to go and meats and cheeses along with fruit cups if you need to stop in and grab something before going to the end of the island to fish, or off island. Prices are reasonable for the area and gourmet vibe!

Ashlyn Donovan

Dec 29, 2025

We were so excited to see a coffee shop come to the island! I had a blueberry donut and it was delightful! The coffee is simple yet delicious. I can’t wait to be back morning after morning supporting Lucy’s!

Erin Lonergan

Dec 24, 2025

It’s so nice having a quick service option on Plum Island — something we really haven’t had. The breakfast sandwiches were great (on their homemade English muffins), the raspberry scone was delicious, and the iced coffee was fine. Hoping to see an expanded coffee menu once they’re really off to the races!

Bruce

Dec 08, 2025

Great little place on Plum Island. I've tried a few different food items and everything has been really good. The staff there are super friendly .